4.13.2011

death...

Something different today: a little bit of fiction for you. I wrote the piece below when I was about 17, and recently rediscovered it in my long-lost Trapper Keeper full of Secrets. It may be the only thing I ever publicly reveal from the Trapper Keeper of Secrets, as it is about the only thing that I think still (sort of) stands up after all these years - that I could ever want to claim credit for. And perhaps I should not be so quick to claim credit even for this. On second thought, feel free to avert your eyes and come back another time. This could be a real downer.

I am prompted to share it today for a few reasons... a number of people dear to me have recently lost loved ones - within just days of each other in some cases - so the subject of death and grief has been close at hand. I know what it is to mourn, but I have a difficult time really showing empathy in most situations. I will spare you all the introspection and self-analysis, and hope it suffices to say that it's much easier for me to fictionalize death than to actually deal with it in the real world.

Plus, the Smiths have been pretty high in the iTunes rotation lately, and with all my lenten hand-wringing and angst, a piece from my own teenage melodrama seems to be apropos.

The piece below is not meant to address any of the specific, recent situations I mentioned - as I said, this was written mumblegarbletwentysomethinggurble years ago - but some aspects of grief are universal; I like to think there are a couple that come through here. Don't worry, it's not too long - scroll down and see for yourself.

The room was musty, warm, and very quiet. Caroline sat in the vinyl-backed chair, staring at the ebony coffin. She heard Jessica behind her, sobbing softly. She wished her tears would fall as easily. Though safely hidden behind her black veil, she did not cry.
More people came in. People from the company. They all came to her to offer her their sympathies. The room began to fill, adding heat to the stale air. Distracted by the wight of the air, she idly wondered why a place such as this would have such poor ventilation. She glanced around. Except for the two chairs on either side of her, the room seemed full. Caroline felt diseased. Not one could bring himself to associate with her. Not that she couldn't hear their whisperings: "Such a shame... so young...", "And now of all times...", "It must be so terrible for her...", "The poor dear..."
Caroline raised her head. Some bigwig from the company was reading the eulogy. She didn't quite remember him; she wondered if Jess had asked him to do this. Jess had been doing so much for her, and as Caroline listened to her crying quietly, she realised how hard it must be, even for her. The three of them had always been good friends. She'd especially have to thank Jess when this mess was all over. Maybe they'd take her out one night, like they used to, and -
They.
There was no more "they." No us, no we, no nothing.
She stared at the coffin.
The fever of Caroline's isolation had broken. She stood next to Jess and Andy, their presence offering her the support she needed. She half listened to what the minister was saying as they stood graveside. She wondered what would happen next. Probably she'd have to open her house to these people, let them comfort her, or at least try to. She'd rather be alone.
Thunder rumbled in the distance. The sky was overcast and a slight drizzle fell over the cemetery - not unusual. Perfect funeral weather. Caroline was aware of the large, black umbrella over her and Jess; it seemed more ominous than the sky. She stared across the gray-green grass of the cemetery, dotted with headstones and monuments. Over the next hill was a forest, blackened by clouds and rain; she felt a sudden urge to go take a walk through it. The minister stopped talking; Caroline hadn't heard a word he said.
She stared into the grave. The edges of the coffin blended into the blackness of the grave. The white lilies resting on top looked paradoxical in their brightness, but black orchids would not have suited the occasion in Caroline's eyes. The minister concluded his service, and the people began to drift away. Jess and Andy stayed with her, but no one else approached her. She supposed they didn't want to disturb her in her "grief."
Jess was wiping away her tears. Andy tried to pull Caroline away, but she could not take her eyes from the grave. The coffin locked in her eyesight, she thought about what was in there. The good times, the bad times, the love... He was everything to her, her whole life, locked up in a fancy box in a hole in the ground. Caroline's eyes watered. No more days in the city, no more nights by the fire, no hellos, no goodbyes, no arguments, no games with the kids, no one to say "I love you" when she was down, no one to share her successes and failures, no one, nothing. Ever again. The meaning of never took root in Caroline's mind and grew like a weed, inhabiting every crack and crevice in her brain, taking over, obliterating all other thoughts. Never...
Caroline was aware of a gentle tug at her elbow, aware of fresh earth falling on top of a coffin, aware of mournful tears sliding from her eyes.

Okay - so now that I have typed this out, I feel a need for a little afterthought. I am struck by how depressing this is, and I will pinpoint the idea that makes me cringe (well, one of them, anyway): Never. I couldn't tell you if I really believed at the time that death was so final, so eternal - it is fiction, after all. But I find it interesting how I recoil from it now: as I read along, I might criticize my choice of words, my lack of depth and detail, my still-immature perspective, but I don't argue the sentiment or the substance - the truth of the feelings, if you'll forgive me - until I get to the part where she thinks her whole world has come to an end.

Partly I am offended because of my own beliefs - I cannot view death with such finality myself any longer, because I know better now. I know that when I die someday, it will only be so I can go home and finally be where I belong. Not that I would make light of grief - I hope I am the last person who would do that - but that I consider it a temporary condition. But when I try to put myself in Caroline's shoes, mourning the death of her husband (or so I presume), I can't really sympathize with the idea of never. Not for me, and not for my husband, anyway. Of course, I get that it's fiction, and I suppose that for Caroline, her circumstance is just that final and forever - but it doesn't ring true for me.

And partly, I am offended as a woman to think that a (presumably) young woman might be so wrapped up in another person that she can't see beyond him; can't imagine a way to live beyond him. It's exactly what I'm writing against in my current project, so perhaps that is the core of my discomfort here.

I will spare you all some of the conclusions forming in my head about all of this... I think I will even spare myself most of them. But if you have any thoughts or opinions or conclusions of your own, I'd love to hear them.

1 comment:

RuthAnne said...

Actually, what I got from the passage was that Caroline was a very young widow. Religious beliefs aside, I don't think we can see life without our "true love" when we're young. I don't think it's until we're "older" (late 20s-early 30s or so) that we realize there really is a life outside our lover. Or maybe that's just my personal experience....

I didn't find it depressing, in fact, I think it very accurately caught the emotions of a young widow as she moved from disbelief/shock into the beginning realization of life without her lover. I thought it was pretty asute/"deep" for a 17 year old.