2.02.2011

back in the saddle

Clearly, I am not so good at this blogging thing; if you are checking my archives, you'll see it's been quite literally years since I did much work with this. So, just don't go there; I'd be embarrassed to think how much I have changed - not to mention how much I have not changed - and you wouldn't enjoy it no matter what.

I am hoping, however, to discipline myself with regard to my writing... I suppose this could mean many different things, but what I am going for (today at least) is some consistency of effort. And maybe some balance in subject matter.

Besides, I do occasionally have thoughts and opinions (which can surprise no one who knows me) that don't make for friendly, pithy, uplifting, or casual Facebook chatter. So rather than force my cranky, whiny, futile, or poorly-thought-out screeds on all my friends, I have another outlet. Hence, I hereby resurrect the blog.

Today's topic is inspired by my son's recent 5th grade writing assignment, to write about someone you know with a disability.

I grew up with PBS and Sesame Street and all sorts of bunny-hugging tolerance and acceptance and understanding, and I hope I am passing on a useful measure of this to my children. But this assignment has stymied both me and my son, and I wonder if it is a matter of perspective. My son has struggled for not really knowing anyone with a disability - or not knowing them well enough to write about it. Certainly there are people whose lives intersect with my family who might, by any reasonable definition, be considered 'disabled,' but my knee-jerk reaction is to look for what we used to call 'handicaps'. And we don't see a lot of those in the people around us.

My son's teacher assures me that none of the other kids in his class have had any trouble coming up with an appropriate subject for this essay, and putting aside for a moment the question of whether or not my son is actually just shirking the assignment, I realize that if I had to write such a paper I would be at a loss myself. Certainly I know people with different degrees of disability, and I probably know one or two people who have disabilities I am not aware of. But my skin crawls to think of having to point out someone I know, label them 'disabled', and write about them as though it was their disability that made them interesting. (In fairness, I believe the actual assignment is to write about how you know them, NOT about how they are disabled; which only makes me wonder why the subject of the essay should be disabled in the first place.)

So I've been wondering if my own definition of 'disabled' is somehow too warped or narrow for this assignment; which makes me wonder if I am doing my children a disservice in the way we address (or, apparently, do not address) disabilities. Or, does our family's social life just lack the kind of diversity that makes for a well-rounded cast of Sesame Street? Are we unconsciously guilty of everything that Big Bird and Grover tried to teach us not to do - are we surrounding ourselves with people who look just like us and shunning anyone who is different? (A thought which horrifies me, by the way.)

What qualifies as a disability? blindness? paraplegia? downs syndrome? dyslexia? ADD? color-blindness? depression? Naturally we don't encourage our children to point and stare, but neither do we expect they would assume someone's 'disability' renders them incapable of a normal life. We teach our children to respect that everyone has challenges of one kind or another - ourselves included. Some people may have challenges that we don't and sometimes can't understand: what those challenges are, to me anyway, are mostly irrelevant. Everybody needs some kind of help at least some of the time. Respect that, and don't get wrapped up in the details.

Thoughts? opinions?

No comments: